The culture and temperament

Table of Contents Culture and Personality Cultural psychologists have noted that some aspects of personality differ across cultural groups.

Most of the extant literature has developed around Asian-North American or Western European comparisons. Mothers used the Infant Behavioral Questionnaire IBQ-R to record the frequency of different behaviors their children displayed at six and 12 months after birth.

Culture and personality was one of the reactions against the 19th social evolution and diffusionism just as the functionalism school of Radcliff-Brown and Malinowski was. Across all ages, Americans received higher ratings on temperamental fearfulness than Finnish individuals, and also demonstrated higher levels of other negative affects at several time points.

A second advance represented by the current effort is the utilization of instruments which are more detailed than those used by Miettunen et al. This essentially monocultural tradition imposes limitations on our understanding of the acculturation of child temperament and on extant theories of temperament.

Overall, Italian and Australian mothers described their toddlers in ways that were the most temperamentally different, with the Italo-Australians in between. He worked on ethnographies of Melanesians and American Indians and partnered with Abram Kardiner to develop the personality mediation view.

Infant temperaments may reflect parents’ cultural values

Mothers of three-month-old infants were recruited via telephone calls made on the basis of birth announcements published in Eugene-Springfield, OR, local newspapers.

Table 1 contains culture-specific means and standard deviations, and statistics for cultural effects. Her well-known contribution was to the configuration view of Culture and Personality.

LeVine puts the beginning with W. A second view was that anti-culture-personality relationship. Children Two hundred and twenty four females parents of 5-year old children participating in a longitudinal study beginning at 18 months completed the CBQ.

Early Childhood Temperament in Three U.

Does Culture Affect our Personality?

Mothers declining participation cited concerns with the time demands of a longitudinal study. We studied children from three cultural backgrounds in the United States: Sick and preterm babies were not included in the study. The item parent-report instrument assesses six scales: The United States scores very high on rankings of Individualism and Masculinity, whereas Finland, although also considered an individualist country, scores moderately on these dimensions.

At this time the infants averaged 6 months of age. Benedict conducted fieldwork among American Indians, contemporary European and Asian societies. It held that culture and personality interact and balance one another. InCora Dubois, Abram Kardiner and Ralph Linton coauthored the book, the Psychological Frontiers of Society which consisted of careful descriptions and interpretations of three cultures the Comanche culture, the Alorese culture, and the culture of an American rural community.

The study of early child temperament in acculturating groups provides an especially compelling locus for examining different possibilities. American culture promotes a view of the self as independent. Notably, Axia et al.

Child Temperament in Three U.S. Cultural Groups

Freud and those who followed him were contenders of this view. Personality becomes an intervening variable. Data collected in 18 countries Cornelia Kirchhoff, a clinical psychology graduate student, is working with Gartstein to wrap up a study comparing the impact of child temperament on behavioral problems for infants in the United States and Germany.

The dyads were a consecutive series of mothers with singleton healthy births in It took the stance that the culture and personality were so interconnected that they could not be viewed separately.

Evidence to date supports the careful use of parent-report measures of child temperament for several reasons: This view reconciled sociological and cultural approached with that of psychological reductionism.


The views of Franz Boas and some his students such as Ruth Benedict argued against that of the early evolutionists, such as Louis Henry Morgan and Edward Tylor, who believe each culture goes through the same hierarchical evolutionary system.

This was a universal phenomenon in which a group of unconscious feelings and ideas centered on the desire to possess the parent of the opposite sex and the harboring of hostility towards the parent of the same sex.

Culture-and-personality studies

Child care arrangements represent a primary component of physical and social settings. They learn to rely on others, to be modest about achievements, and to fit into groups.

For example, Americans and Asians have slightly different conceptions of self.Culture and Personality Petrina Kelly and Xia Chao and Andrew Scruggs and Lucy Lawrence and Katherine Mcghee-Snow (Note: authorship is arranged stratigraphically with the most recent author listed first) Basic Premises: The culture and personality movement was at the core of anthropology in the first half of the 20th century.

The culture in which the child is raised has an affect on them and that can adjust their temperament accordingly. For example, in the Japanese culture, mothers usually cay that their child is born as an independent who must learn to rely on their parents by staying in close contact with them.

Request PDF on ResearchGate | On Dec 8,X. Chen and others published Culture and temperament. Culture-and-personality studies, also called psychological anthropology, branch of cultural anthropology that seeks to determine the range of personality types extant in a given culture and to discern where, on a continuum from ideal to perverse, the culture places each type.

The type perceived as. Culture & Temperament Are temperament differences universal? If temperament is biologically based, is it found in all cultures? Temperamental differences in behavior are found in all cultures but individual differences in behavioral style may have different implications in environments other than our own.

“The influence temperament has on developing behavioral problems likely varies from one country to another,” Gartstein said.

“If we are aiming to prevent behavioral problems, which are a known precursor for more serious psychological problems, we need to know more about the values and expectations parents bring to the child-rearing table.”.

The culture and temperament
Rated 3/5 based on 54 review